15 Villages at Risk; Who Will Take Responsibility for Public Money? No Protection for Naltona for Decades

Tk 1.47 Crore Embankment in Barguna Starts Collapsing Within Just Six Weeks

An embankment and sand-filled geo-bags were built at a cost of nearly Tk 1.5 crore to protect local communities from river erosion. However, less than six weeks after the work was completed, the embankment has started collapsing due to erosion by the Payra River.

In some places, parts of the embankment, along with geo-bags, are disappearing into the river. Large cracks have also appeared in other places. There are fears that the embankment could collapse at any time, allowing water to enter nearby homes and villages. At least 15 villages in Taltali upazila are now at risk.

Meanwhile, people in several villages near the river in Naltona Union of Barguna Sadar upazila are still living in fear because the embankment, which was washed away by river erosion decades ago, has not been rebuilt permanently. Whenever a warning is issued for a low-pressure system or cyclone, their worries increase.

For people living in the river-surrounded areas of coastal Barguna, river erosion and tidal surges are not new threats. Memories of past disasters return whenever a low-pressure system forms in the Bay of Bengal or a cyclone threatens the coast.

People spend sleepless nights wondering when river water will rise, when weak embankments will collapse and when they may face another disaster like Cyclone Sidr. This fear is now becoming a reality in the Tetulbaria-Nalbunia area of Nishanbaria Union in Taltali upazila.

Under five packages of the Water Development Board (WDB), 590 metres of embankment were repaired and geo-bags were placed at a contract cost of Tk 1 crore 47 lakh 74 thousand. Four contractor companies carried out the work.

Although the work was scheduled to be completed in September, questions have already been raised about the project’s durability. According to information collected from the site, around 300 metres of the repaired embankment and geo-bag section are collapsing into the river. Large cracks have appeared along nearly 200 metres of the flood-control embankment.

In some places, the soil has washed away, exposing the inner part of the embankment. Local people fear that upcoming high tides, low-pressure systems or cyclones could cause further damage. Local resident Rafiqul Islam said, “We had concerns about the quality of the work from the beginning. We saw that soil was taken from the riverbank to build the embankment. Now, within a short time, cracks have appeared and geo-bags are falling into the river. If the water level rises during high tide, it will be difficult for us to protect our homes.”

Another resident of the area, Amena Begum, said, “Our homes and farmland are close to the river. If the embankment breaks, not only our houses but also our paddy fields and fish farms will go under water. We want a permanent embankment. We do not want to live in fear every year.” Local people have alleged that the situation was caused by the use of low-quality materials and insufficient sand in the geo-bags.

The problem is not limited to Taltali. Communities along the river in Naltona Union of Barguna Sadar upazila have also been facing a long-standing crisis over the lack of proper embankments.

People in villages such as Azgarkathi, Majher Char, Jintala, Padma, Ruhitar, Paler Baliatali and Agapadma become worried whenever they hear news of floods or tidal surges. River erosion has already destroyed homes and farmland in many parts of these areas. Local people said many families in Azgarkathi had lost their homes due to river erosion and were forced to move elsewhere.

Residents said a large section of the embankment in the area was washed away by river erosion several decades ago. However, even after all these years, no lasting steps have been taken to rebuild a strong embankment or protect the riverbank. As a result, the area remains at risk even during normal high tides. The fear becomes greater whenever there is a warning of a low-pressure system or cyclone. They fear that a major disaster could flood a large area because of the weak protection system.

Local social worker Selim Shahnewaz said, “People living along the river in Naltona Union have been suffering for a long time. Many families in Azgarkathi have lost their homes due to river erosion. The embankment disappeared into the river decades ago, but there is still no permanent solution. People become frightened whenever they hear news of a low-pressure system or cyclone.

“We want more than temporary repairs. Strong embankments must be built by considering the river’s movement and the actual conditions of the area. Effective steps must also be taken to protect the riverbanks in erosion-prone areas.”

The lives and livelihoods of people in at least 15 villages, including Tetulbaria, Baro Ankhu Jan, Nalbunia and Agapara in Taltali, now depend on the safety of the weak embankment. Similar uncertainty exists in the riverside villages of Naltona.

If the embankments collapse, homes, Aman paddy fields, farmland and fish farms could be flooded. The supply of safe drinking water, communication systems and normal life could also be badly affected.

Questions have been raised about how an embankment built under a project worth nearly Tk 1.5 crore could reach such a poor condition within just six weeks of completion. It is also important to find out how the quality of the construction work was checked and whether proper supervision was carried out before measuring the work and paying the contractors.

The reasons for the lack of permanent embankment construction in long-affected areas such as Naltona also need to be explained.

People are also asking how those responsible for carrying out and supervising these projects will be held accountable if public money is spent but local communities remain unsafe.

Regarding the matter, Barguna Water Development Board Executive Engineer Md Abdul Hannan Pradhan said the river was far from the embankment when the work was carried out in Taltali. Later, erosion started at the riverbed, making it difficult to control the situation with geo-bags alone. He said a project proposal had been sent to higher authorities to build a lasting riverbank protection system using concrete blocks and geo-bags.

However, he said a permanent solution was not possible at the moment due to a lack of necessary funds. He also said a proposal had been sent to higher authorities to start work on the embankment in Naltona Union as soon as possible.

People in the coastal areas are demanding effective protection measures before disasters occur, rather than relief after disasters or temporary repairs to damaged embankments.

They say the damaged sections of the newly built embankment in Taltali must be repaired quickly. The project also needs technical and financial audits. At the same time, a strong and permanent embankment must be built to protect the people of Naltona, who have remained exposed to river erosion for decades.

Otherwise, even after spending crores of taka in public money, people in coastal areas will continue to face the threats of river erosion and tidal surges.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *