Secularism and modernity; is Islam lagging behind?

‘Religion and state are separate’ – this sentence is one of the main slogans of modernity in today’s world. But the question is, is this thought not merely a regional reaction born from the painful experience of European history? When the Christian Church of the Middle Ages took a stand against science, secularism became the slogan of European liberation. Has Islam ever opposed science? Or has religion ever prevented human liberation? At the very beginning of Islam, the first word of the Quran was ‘Iqra’, meaning read. The Holy Prophet (PBUH) said, ‘The pursuit of knowledge is obligatory upon every Muslim man and woman.’

While Europe was in darkness, Islamic civilization was going through a golden age of knowledge during the Abbasid Caliphate (especially Baghdad) with the establishment of the ‘Baitul Hikma’ knowledge house and Al-Khwarizmi, Al-Razi, Ibn Sina, Ibnul Haytham, Al-Farabi. Then I will leave out the mention of Imam Ghazali, Maulana Jalaluddin Rumi. There are hundreds of Muslim scholars, whose list would be a long one. During this time, the Muslim world made unprecedented progress in science, medicine, astronomy and mathematics, which was a huge contrast to the dark ages of Europe. In other words, Islam did not create modernity, but laid the foundation for modernity. The secularism that was born against the monopolistic power of the European Church was introduced in the Muslim world by colonialism in a way, ‘Religion is your personal matter, it has no place in the state.’ After the fall of the Mughal Caliphate in India, the British government excluded religion from education and administration. The secular Kemal Ataturk abolished Sharia in Turkey and introduced a European code. In Arab countries, Western puppet governments also stripped religion of its spirit and reduced it to mere ritual. The goal of secularism was to free state morality and law from the provisions of Allah and establish man-made commercial, colonial control. The French philosopher Michel Foucault himself admitted that modernity is not a doctrine, but a strategy for the transformation of power. Western modernity does not mean just technology; it is a dangerous moral liberation in history, where the right to same-sex marriage is praised as ‘development’. Where the symbolism of religious dress or customs is presented as ‘backwardness’.
Islam wants development, but not moral decline. Islam rejects consumerism and the worship of lust behind the mask of human rights. Today, many say that the Caliphate or Islamic state system is impractical, undemocratic, and outdated. This statement is actually the teaching of colonial textbooks imposed from above. However, the Caliphate was a ruler like Omar Ibnul Khattab (RA), who gave freedom to the judge. Under the Umayyad-Abbasid rule, hundreds of nations and languages ​​coexisted under one umbrella. The Baytul Mal (government fund) was transparent like a mirror. Therefore, the Islamic state system is never a dictatorship, but it can be said to be the highest moral and faith-based state policy. Although there are different talks about some rulers of the Umayyad and Abbasid Caliphate regimes, it is not related to the entire regime. There was a combination of good and evil. One of the places where the secular attitude misrepresents Islam is that Islam is against science and reason. While the Judeo-Christian scriptures contain numerous scientific errors in their cosmology and interpretation of the biological world, the Quran states: ‘…and We created from water every living thing…’ (Surah Al-Anbiya, verse 30) ‘The moon and the sun move in measured courses.’ (Surah Ar-Rahman, verse 5)

The numerous facts of modern cosmology, biogenesis and physics are in perfect harmony with the verses of the Quran today. Islam is never the enemy of modernity, Islam is the true standard of modernity. If modernity means knowledge, order, unity, justice and moral development, then Islam is its ideal model. But if modernity means secular consumerism, family collapse and the legitimacy of degradation, then Islam is definitely against that modernity. History says that the state system is never neutral. Behind it lies philosophy, goals and the thought of a class of authority. After the fall of the Caliphate, a political philosophy called democracy emerged in the Muslim world, the source of which is a moral reaction originating from the European Christian Middle Ages. The question is, who is behind the fall of the Caliphate? Has democracy been able to fill that void? The Caliphate does not mean just a system of governance, but it can be said to be a just and moral flow of authority based on monotheism. The first era of the Caliphate – the rule based on the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad, under the Surah-based leadership of the four Caliphs, was based on social justice, economic equality, and the excellence of knowledge.

At a critical juncture in history, Europe gave birth to a new philosophy called secularism, demanding the separation of religion from the state. On the other hand, the Islamic state system is an inseparable combination of religion and state. A revolutionary combination of spirituality and law. Which of the secular state system and Islamic state policy ideals is more effective and sustainable? In medieval Europe, the authority of the Church was unlimited. However, the basis of that authority was religious persecution and hostility to knowledge. The trial of Galileo shows that church power meant a closed door to thought. Starting with the French Revolution (1789), the Enlightenment movement pushed Europe towards a knowledge-based but anti-religious state system. This is where the idea that religion is a personal matter, and the state will be neutral, was born. But in reality, the secular state is a paradise for the rich, a nightmare for the poor. It makes religion a culture and creates a moral vacuum.

In Islam, religion and state complement each other. Here, the Quran not only prescribes prayers and fasting, but also determines financial justice, criminal law, war policy, the process of governance, and even taxation. The Prophet (PBUH) established an Islamic state in Medina, the main features of which were social justice, freedom of religious minorities, the rule of law, and a tax-based revenue system. Western society wants the law to create a state. Islam says that the law is determined by Allah, and the state will implement it. France bans Muslim women’s hijab under the pretext of secularism, and India is secular but torture against others is legal. Even though America says ‘church and state are separate’, the president takes an oath by touching the Bible. Another event, which is simultaneously historical, political, and theological. Its mystery has not been fully revealed to this day, but we can see its echo in a dramatic geopolitical shift that took place in 1917. At that time, secular Europe achieved the historic success of liberating Jerusalem, a holy land for Muslims. The Crusades, which began almost a millennium ago under the leadership of European Christians, seemed to have achieved their long-awaited successful outcome in 1917. If Christian Europe’s fascination with the Holy Land is a thousand years old, then the question is, why is the current Europe, which is indifferent to religion and even largely secular, so keen on recovering the Holy Land? Isn’t it a sign of their self-contradiction to launch the movement to liberate Jerusalem out of theological passion, where religion plays no role in their state and moral policy-making?

Islam says that Allah’s law is beneficial for all people. Secularism says that religion is personal, but if you practice another religion outside of a specific religion, the state will intervene. These masked secularists do not even take the time to label you a terrorist. John Locke, Rousseau, Hegel – although they played a role in writing the philosophy of secularism, there was a deep hesitation in their thoughts. John Locke said, ‘Religion can be limited to personal freedom, but only to the question of state security.’ Hegel said, ‘The state will be the full form of morality.’ But where will morality come from? Islam says that morality comes from the word of Allah, which is the permanent foundation of justice for human civilization. Kemal Ataturk’s Turkey is a state suffering from an identity crisis. Muslim oppression and naked attacks on Islam are being carried out by bringing up the issue of terrorism and threatening it. Egypt’s elected Islamists were removed and a pro-Western military regime was imposed. Abdel Fattah al-Sisi is its holder and protector. The way secularism is being imposed on the Muslim world today is nothing more than a cultural colonization.

Author: Lecturer, Government Ispahani College, Keraniganj, Dhaka.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *